Hi @b.rosenberg_ERG if this is still an issue, I think troubleshooting will require seeing your input data for each run as well. It’s also worth looking inside each of the CSV file inputs for the different scenarios and confirm that they do in fact point to different sets of GIS data.
From your logs, I can see that you used a different workspace directory for each scenario. That’s a good idea, and it makes it very hard to explain how the results could be identical unless the input data were also mistakenly identical.